Minutes of Roborough Investment Club Meeting #65
20th Sep 2004

Attendees:
Andrew Watkins,  Wez Davey, Alan Martin, Andy Davies, Chris Bailey, Geoff Floyd, Franz Fuchs, Cyril Bouhallier

Apologies:
Alan Proudfoot (osb), Phil Ainsley

Absent:
Les Watson (osb)

Agenda:

Review minutes of previous meeting
Review of actions
Treasurer's report
Review of current holdings
AOB
Agenda for next meeting

1. Review minutes of previous meeting

Previous meeting's minutes approved.

2. Review Actions

Action of Geoff to provide an asset summary for last month completed.

3. Treasurer's Report

We have sold Volex and Brtish Empire. We made a small lost on both. Since selling they have both recovered.
The concern was raised (by Andy) that the Cowboys are selling shares too quickly and losing money when they recover .
We received a dividend of £10.29 from Hardy and Hanson, and an outstanding £145.71 and £9.01 from LSE. The unit price has gone up 3p to 103p. Full detals below.

Shares purchase/sales this month

Sell

British Empire (on 17Aug) for £916.15 (£83.49 loss)
Volex (on 10Aug) for £966.58 (£45.40 loss)

Purchase

Associated British Ports (on 17th Aug) for £997.43
Isoft (on 10th August) for £997.66
 

Dividends Received

Hardy and Hansons £10.29
London Stock Exchange £154.76

Asset Summary


 
Name of Company
No shares
Average price
Total Cost
Selling price
Net selling value
Profit or loss to date
Change during month
%
Cowboys Assocaited British ports
241
414.52
998.99
430.75
1025.61
26.62
26.62
2.60
  Hardys & Hansons
143
424.33
606.79
505
709.65
102.86
0.00
0.00
  Kelda
505
396.83
2004.01
527.5
2561.38
647.37
58.08
2.19
  UK Coal
641
155.82
998.78
165
1045.18
46.37
163.45
15.64
  Isoft
294
339.26
997.43
360
1045.90
48.47
48.47
4.63
Bulls Bovis Homes
223
447.81
998.61
560
1236.30
237.69
102.58
8.30
  Brown (N) Group
800
124.06
992.50
117.25
925.50
-67.00
88.00
9.51
  Creative Education
9825
10.18
999.91
4.63
442.40
-557.51
-49.12
-11.10
  Eckoch Technology
2000
39.13
782.56
8.38
155.10
-627.46
-12.40
-7.99
  London Stock Exch
265
376.54
997.82
357
933.55
-64.27
2.65
0.28
  Pennon Group
150
678.17
1017.25
817.5
1213.75
196.50
131.25
10.81
  Personal
525
190.95
1002.49
182.5
945.33
-56.86
-10.50
-1.11
  Rank
385
259.73
999.97
287
1092.45
92.48
-33.69
-3.08
  Royal Doulton
6361
12.14
771.97
6.63
409.23
-362.74
-63.61
-15.54
   
14169.08
13831.60
-337.48
451.78
3.27%

Unit price rises from 100 to 103p.

4. Review of current holdings

Cowboys:

Associated British Ports  - recent buy bought as a recovery stock after recent bad news had hit share price. It is hoped they will rise (up 2.6% so far).

Isoft - second buy this month tracking upwards (4.65%). Will hold.

Hardys and Hansons - continuing flat/upwards, waiting for the turn.

Kelda - monitoring very closely. It is felt that these are now fully valued and could turn. Bulls made an offer to purchase the share from Cowboys at 400p. This offer was rejected.

UK Coal - Good month up 15.64%. Will continue to monitor.
 

Bulls:

Bovis Homes. The group are divided on how to handle this share (hold or sell). There is a move towards selling them, but the group are waiting until the shares reach 600p.

Brown Group - Share up 8.3% this month. Brown Group provide catelogue sales for the older/grey polulation, and should be stable.

Eckoch Technology - Down 8% this month. Holding.

London Stock Exchange - Great divident this month. Holding.

Royal Daulton - Very volatile share. The original strategy was to buy as a recovery share, bought after bad news and restructuring. It is hoped that the price will rise now that they are at the end of their recovery plan. However they are not yet in profit.

Personal - Bought on technical analysis basis - good yield, PEG, P/E. Will hold.
 

5. AOB

Two concerns were raised:

1) Lack of attendence by some members of the group is hampering share dealing. The bulls and cowboys have different strategies for buying / selling shares. The cowboys apply a 50% rule for those attending the weekly meeting to make purchase/sell decisions. The bulls apply a 50% rule for the whole group rule regardless of who attends weekly meetings. Consequently if less than 50% of the members meet, no decisions are possible without using e-mail.

2) Lack of new members / general interest. Chris was concerned that the group was running out of fresh ideas and stagnating. Interest seems to have waned now that the stock market is tracking sideways. He beleives that an import of active new members would be beneficial.
 

6. Agenda for next meeting

Review minutes of previous meeting
Review of actions
Treasurer's report
Review of current holdings
AOB
Agenda for next meeting
Action Summary

Andy took an action to look through previous minutes to determine if they are rules / proceedures for dealing with members who do not attend a sufficient number of weekly / monthly meetings.

Date of next meeting

Monday, 18th October 2004, 5.00pm to 6.00pm